1. Health
You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.

Stroke vs Migraine

By January 16, 2008

Recently a close friend called me in panic to ask me whether I thought she might be having a stroke. At first, she described her symptoms as 10 minutes of partial blindness in the "left side of the world". This could indeed be a stroke, I thought to myself, and started to prepare her for an emergent trip to the nearest hospital. But as I started to ask more and more questions about the event, it became obvious that instead of a stroke, my friend was having a migranous aura. How could I tell? I simply asked her whether she had seen any flashing lights in her vision. And she had. In fact, she still could see them out of the corner of both eyes. They were white and flashing, and bothered her to the point that she needed to keep her eyes closed and stay still.

Her description of this event is classic for a migrainous aura, and not classic at all for a stroke. Strokes typically manifest themselves as “negative phenomena”, or as the unnoticeable absence of previously intact function. Typically people who suffer a stroke take some time to realize that they have lost a certain body function. This is in part why people who suffer a stroke while they are sleeping never notice it until after they wake up in the morning.

Thus, a stroke that affects a person’s vision is usually not noticed by that person for some time, until she begins to notice that she is constantly bumping into things, usually on one side of the body, over and over again. Migraines, on the other hand, lead to “positive phenomena” which is felt by that person as a bothersome, painful, or annoying symptoms such as the painful flashing lights that my friend described to me over the phone.

Having said the above, I must say that the symptoms of a stroke can present in the most unexpected of ways, depending on the part of the brain that is affected. Consequently, it may be virtually impossible to differentiate a stroke from a migraine in some people. I strongly recommend always erring on the side of caution and taking a trip to the nearest emergency room so that brain imaging (CT scan or MRI) can be performed. This way you and your doctors can rest assured that your symptoms are not being caused by a stroke

Comments
January 25, 2008 at 4:14 am
(1) be careful says:

I just returned from the hospital with my mother who was also told the “migraine” she was experiencing was just that, a headache… She had to be rushed in yesterday( a week later) with the flashing ” kaleidoscope” lights on the right side of her vision… she finally got a CT scan and a MRI and has clearly had a stroke. Its best to err in the side of safety. She now doesnt know what year it is, who the president is, or even why she is in the hospital. If someone hadnt just dismissed her ‘migraine’ and sent her home from the doctors office and hospital, she might not have vision loss, and neurological impairment now.

October 27, 2008 at 12:27 pm
(2) lisa says:

Always make sure the ER docs do an mri and a full neuro consult on anyone experiencing those symptoms- never let anyone d/c you for a headeache if they have not done the appropriate tests.

Don’t trust the ER docs- make sure you see a specialist.

Always trust yoru instincts- you know your body better than anyone- do not let som2 25 yrs old kid fresh out of med school ruin your life.

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks are automatic. Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title="">, <b>, <i>, <strike>

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.

We comply with the HONcode standard
for trustworthy health
information: verify here.